I've used Lancome Idole ever since it was bought as a Christmas gift for me, several years ago. I've purchased it several times since. It's the best mascara in my eyes, I have ever used. I use it with an eye lash serum and eye lash curler for maximum results. Lancome Idole doesn't flake or smudge. It separates my lashes without them sticking together. I have had a lot of compliments and input it down to the routine I use and Lancome Idole Mascara.